top of page

Whether Truth Resides Only in the Intellect?

Thank you for subscribing to Annotated Thomist...check back each day for a new section of St. Thomas' corpus, annotated and summarized. (FREE TRIAL FOR NEW SUBSCRIBERS!!!)

AT is also available to donors of $10 or more on Patreon or SubscribeStar along with all of the other benefits (daily bonus videos, bonus articles, PDFs, etc.

If you need more personalized help reading the Summa, I am available for 1-on-1 sessions, here.

cf., Sent.I.D19.Q5.A1; SCG1.C60; QDeVer.Q1.A2; Peri.Bk1.L3; Metaph.Bk6.L4

Here, we begin our discussion of truth.

The first article may seem controversial to many, as if the Angelic doctor is reviving some sort of "subjectivism" where "truth" is something created by individuals and not an objective standard. St. Thomas actually brings forth this objection at the forefront of the article in the Second Objection, "If, then, truth is only in the intellect, nothing will be true except in so far as it is understood. But this is the error of the ancient philosophers, who said that whatever seems to be true is so. Consequently mutual contradictories seem to be true as seen by different persons at the same time."

Yet, if we remember what had come before in the fifteenth question on ideas, the answer will make much more sense and provide us with quite a few points of profound reflection.

He begins the article by comparing the nature of the good (which was already covered in Q. 5) to the nature of truth by comparing the nature of the appetite (whose object is the good) and the nature of the intellect (whose object is the true).

Want to read more?

Subscribe to to keep reading this exclusive post.

9 views0 comments


bottom of page